Worst Presidential Decision In History?

Last week I opened this column by saying I believe President Biden’s decision to abruptly pull our troops and air support out of Afghanistan before getting American civilians and Afghan supporters out will go down as one of the worst decisions ever made by an American president. Apparently, most Americans agree as evidenced by Mr. Biden’s crash in the polls.

Today, I’m reprinting an editorial that appeared yesterday in Issues & Insights, which I read frequently for news and political opinion. This article echoes my feeling that President Biden just made one of the worst decisions in US political history by pulling our troops out of Afghanistan before getting our citizens and allies out of the country first.

Note that the emphasis (bolding) is mine. I hope you enjoy.

“Americans Await Evacuation As
Biden Takes A Knee To Taliban
Issues & Insights August 25, 2021

When President Joe Biden met with this year’s WNBA champions Seattle Storm in the White House on Monday, he took a symbolic knee, apparently to show he’s Woke. No surprise. He just took a knee before the Taliban, too, after the terrorist group’s humiliating rejection of his request for an “extension” on his Aug. 31 deadline for evacuating Afghanistan.

Biden’s plans, if you can call them that, to get Americans out of Afghanistan have been an epic disaster. It’s almost impossible to exaggerate the incompetence and duplicity of Biden and his administration.

Biden rejected extending the [evacuation] deadline, citing the “increased risk” of terrorism as a reason for doing so. The fact is, he really had no choice, after the Taliban rejected the U.S. plea, calling the Aug. 31 deadline for withdrawal a “red line.” The U.S. president did what the Taliban told him to do

“If the U.S. or U.K. were to seek additional time to continue evacuations, the answer is no,” said Taliban official Suhail Shaheen. “Or there would be consequences.”

Adding insult to injury, Biden told our allies that the U.S. “won’t be able to get everyone out of Afghanistan,” according to Bloomberg. Meanwhile, twisting the knife, the Taliban demanded that the U.S. take only Americans, not Afghans, with them.

Late in the day, facing a barrage of criticism from all quarters, Biden appeared to abruptly change tack, calling for “contingency plans” for lengthening the withdrawal, whatever that means.

… in a brief two-week period [the Biden administration] has managed to alienate and weaken our major allies while emboldening and empowering our foes, in particular Russia, China, Iran and the myriad Islamist terrorist groups across the Mideast and South Asia.

And things are about to get even uglier in Afghanistan, if that’s possible.

The good news is that, as of Monday, the U.S. had already helped evacuate 37,000 people from Afghanistan, according to a leaked ambassadorial communication. The bad news: Only 4,000 Americans were among those evacuated.

The U.S., despite having the biggest airlift capacity on Earth, has had to rely on private carriers to evacuate the country, at the same time doing little to get stranded American citizens into the airport, say some.

“The South Africans, the Brits, the Qataris, their ambassadors have been getting safe passage for people to the airport,” said former congressman and one-time Navy SEAL Scott Taylor, who is working with others to privately evacuate people from Kabul.

Taylor, in remarks to the Daily Caller, called the U.S. refusal to aid private groups such as his “frustrating” and, in even blunter terms…

There remain [by some estimates] 15,000 more Americans and at least 50,000 Afghans to be evacuated, according to recent U.S. estimates. But even the Biden administration admits it doesn’t know how many Americans are even there.

From initial assurances that all would be rescued to Biden’s more recent comment that the U.S. “won’t be able to get everyone out,” it now looks as if a nightmare scenario is unfolding.

It includes possible mass hostage-taking or imprisonment of Americans as “spies,” with abuse, torture and possibly even executions for some. We’ve been here before. Remember the 444 days in Iran from 1979 to 1981, under the Ayatollah Khomeini? The Taliban is even worse. And it’s terrifying to think what it’ll do to those Afghans who helped us these past two decades.

In addition to gifting the now-national Taliban army with billions of dollars in spanking-new U.S. rifles, missile launchers, aircraft and even uniforms, we have now created the potential for the “Largest Hostage Crisis in American History,” as Commentary Online called it.

Begging terrorists for help is a huge mistake for a superpower. Our willful weakness makes the world a far more unstable and dangerous place than it already is.

Do the Democrats in Congress care? It doesn’t seem so. They’ve been moving forward on other things, even as they criticize and distance themselves from the increasingly isolated, politically damaged and mentally failing Biden. His public approval in nearly every poll has collapsed, and Democrats fear the taint of his failure going into 2022.

While the rest of us worry about the utter implosion of U.S. foreign policy, the loss of our prestige and power around the world, and the tragedy of the Afghan people and Americans trapped in Kabul, Democrats in Congress have had their eyes on the real prize.

With little fanfare, they just announced a [massive] $3.5 trillion spending bill that if passed into law will put Americans further in hock for decades to come, raise taxes, kill thousands of small businesses, add to already soaring inflation and give government unprecedented control over all aspects of American life.

“Never let a good crisis go to waste,” as the Democrats like to say.

Whether they now try to remove political liability Biden via the 25th Amendment, making Kamala Harris president [God, help us!], or wait and take their chances in the 2022 midterms, remains to be seen.

But Biden’s total lack of competence can no longer be doubted. He’s failed to push back against the murderous Taliban, set up the possible re-establishment of both al-Qaida and ISIS in Afghan territory, and in effect asked for a mass hostage crisis. Such ineptitude isn’t mere bureaucratic failure; it’s deadly. END QUOTE

 

10 Responses to Worst Presidential Decision In History?

  1. No, the worst presidential decision ever was Donald’s decision to concoct the Big Lie.
    And if the country had been unfortunate enough to re-elect him, he would have pulled the USA out of NATO by now.
    THAT would have been the worst decision ever by a president. Just hypothetically, what would you (Gary) have said about that?

    • Get over your hatred of Trump. You’re speculations are idiotic, at best. If you can support Biden and this Afghanistan mess, then you’re part of the problem with this country.

      What Biden did was not only politically disastrous, it was militarily disastrous, and will haunt us for a long time.

      There is no other way to spin it, so quit trying to blame Trump.

  2. Couldn’t agree more with Charles Aarons. In addition Gary, do you really want to compare what is going on in Afghanistan to the decision by George W.Bush to invade Iraq, a war that killed and wounded how many American service people and Iraqi civilians and got us nothing in return except a stronger and much more dangerous Iran? Time to rethink you sweeping and, in my opinion, naive statement.

    • So you agree this is all Trump’s fault, who didn’t support the war in Iraq? Or maybe you realize you can’t blame Trump, so you had to go all the way back to Bush. So it’s either TDS or BDS, and you need to get over it.

      What about Obama? What did he do to end this mess? Not much. Though you’ll tell me he killed Bin Laden (remember that Biden recommended not doing that?)

      What is happening today is all Biden, and no one else. How anyone can support this man and his policies is beyond me.

      I don’t understand people like you who are lap dogs for the left.

      • This is not about Obama or Trump. I was merely responding to Gary’s assertion that Biden’s decision was the worst presidential decision in history. What has anything you brought up have to do to address what I wrote about? NOTHING!Left or right has nothing to do with what I was addressing.

  3. For others, and for Charles and Aaron, who can’t see how this was an incompetent execution of a plan to get out of Afghanistan, which Trump put into place. Yes, the hated Trump.

    1. You get your civilians out first. All of them. While you still control the territory.
    2. You leave you main military base operational, which is defensible. That’s where you get your civilians out from.
    3. Once your civilians are you, you start getting your equipment out of the country.
    4. Since you still are in control of your airbase, you don’t care about the Kabul airport.
    5. You can withdraw your military forces on your timetable, not your enemies.

    Biden started with step 5 and let the Taliban overrun the country. He’s weak, feckless and not fit to be CIC. We now have Taliban flying Apache helicopters. Biden gave them away. That’s treason.

    No other narrative fits the facts.

    (BTW, spent 25 years in the military, so it’s a subject I’m familiar with).

    • RIGHT ON!! Incompetent decision from incompetent man who unfortunately claims to be president at least 4-6 hours a day!

  4. Since you spent 25 years in the military (I also was in the service), you must be aware of the distances to Bagram vs the airport. Good luck for anyone who would have hypothetically tried to get to Bagram vs the civilian airport, especially without personal motorized transport.
    The only reason this didn’t occur with trump is that he was too chickens**t to do it before an election. Everyone who has studied Afghanistan history for the last 183 or more years knew this was a highly probable outcome.
    I’m not sure you can call evacuation of ~120,000 people, mostly Afghans, in 2 weeks, with the unfortunate death of only 13 NATO/US soldiers, and zero planes shot down, with ISIS-K lurking in the near background.
    As far as hating trump: I will never “get over it”. He tried and continues to try to destroy democracy and trample on the Constitution that I swore to defend. I was actually encouraged when he hired Mattis and Tillerson. Actual intelligent people who put country above venal or partisan interests. We saw how that all ended; even Bill Barr finally saw through him at the end.
    I actually used to frequently support Republicans. I came of age in the 60s and 70s, but the last 5 years have been the most radicalizing time in my life, politically.
    This is like Orwell’s “1984”. The real sheeple aren’t the libtards; they are the lemmings that follow the Koolaid dispensers over the hydroxychloroquin/ivermectin cliff while refusing vaccination, and over the cliff of the Big Lie, which is provably statistically impossible in addition to being evidence-free.
    The fundamental issue is that some people, like me, believe that reality is “out there” in the universe and our little planetary home. Not between our ears, which is only an electrochemical computer for adaptation to the external reality.
    I guess it’s not a coincidence that so many religious fundamentalists support him.

  5. Every President does it. They all make decisions about the world that everyone has a opinion on. Everybody’s guilty in one way or another. So quit whining about who has the worst decision ever made. Politics is a dirty business.